Stock Market Psychology: Behavioral finance, new research, and beyond

Sunday, July 08, 2007

IT'S HERE: Inside the Investor's Brain

After a year-long writing odyssey, it's with great excitement that I announce the release of my new book, Inside the Investor's Brain. You can purchase the book here: Inside the Investor's Brain: The Power of Mind Over Money (Wiley Trading).

The ability to manage your mind in the markets is necessary for long-term trading and investment success. This book teaches the science of achieving high investment returns through an understanding of the power of mind. Endorsements are here. I won't repeat the publishers's long blurb (here: Inside the Investor's Brain: The Power of Mind Over Money (Wiley Trading)), but below is the table of contents:

Introduction.

PART ONE. FOUNDATIONS: THE INTERSECTION OF MIND AND MONEY.
Chapter 1. Markets on the Mind: The challenge of finding an edge.
Chapter 2. Brain Basics: The building blocks.
Chapter 3. Origins of Mind: Expectations, beliefs, and meaning.
Chapter 4. Neurochemistry: This is your brain on drugs.

PART TWO. FEELINGS AND FINANCES.
Chapter 5. Intuition: The power of listening to your gut.
Chapter 6. Money Emotions: Clouding judgment.
Chapter 7. Joy, Hope, and Greed: Hooked on a feeling.
Chapter 8. Overconfidence and Hubris: Too much of a good thing.
Chapter 9. Anxiety, Fear, and Nervousness: How not to panic.
Chapter 10. Stress and burn-out: Short term pleasure, long term pain.
Chapter 11. Love of Risk: Are you trading or gambling?
Chapter 12. Personality Factors: What are great investors like?

PART THREE. THINKING ABOUT MONEY.
Chapter 13. Making Decisions: The effects of probability, ambiguity, and trust.
Chapter 14. Framing Your Options: Seeing the world in black and white.
Chapter 15. Loss Aversion: Cutting losers short and letting winners run.
Chapter 16. Time Discounting: Why we eat dessert first.
Chapter 17. Herding: Keeping up with the Jones’.
Chapter 18. Charting and data mining: Reading tea leaves.
Chapter 19. Attention and Memory: What’s in a name?
Chapter 20. Age, Sex, and Culture: Risk-taking around the world.

PART FOUR. IN PRACTICE.
Chapter 21. Emotion Management: A balancing act.
Chapter 22. Change Techniques: Going deep.
Chapter 23. Behavioral Finance Investing: Playing the players.

Notes.
Glossary.
Index.


It is my sincere hope that Inside the Investor's Brain will help you achieve investment (and life) success beyond your wildest expectations.

Richard

Labels: , , , , , , , , , ,

Monday, May 21, 2007

The Bugs Bunny/Road Runner Investing Hour!


Most of us remember growing up watching cartoons on Saturday morning.

I probably watched too much. It quite literally affected my ability to make sense of the world.

One of my favorites was The Bugs Bunny/Roadrunner Hour that featured the antics of a homicidal supra-genius named Wile E. Coyote who was obsessed with doing harm to a vocab-challenged Road Runner - the Moby Dick to his canine Ahab.

Of course, the coyote never succeeded. He got crushed, flattened and blown up every week. But he did teach us a fascinating lesson of cartoon physics that we can apply to markets -- particularly soaring ones.

In every episode, Wile E. Coyote would invariably pursue his elusive quarry off of a cliff. At this point, it became clear to the audience that the coyote was headed for a serious fall. And the more excitable among us were prone to yell things like, "Look out!" at the TV. The coyote; however, was blissfully unaware of his circumstances. In fact, breaking multiple laws of physics, Wile E. Coyote continued to churn his feet, levitating in the same spot, indefinitely free from all harm... until he did one thing; until he looked down.

Upon looking down, the impossibility (even absurdity) of his current status became clear. The coyote would gulp, usually produce a hastily assembled placard featuring the phrase, "Bye bye!" - and fall like an anvil into the void below.

Welcome to the world of investing bubbles. Welcome to Wile E. Coyote Sydrome (TM).

We've seen it before, throughout the late 90s when people were paying 200 P/Es for stocks based on metrics such as "eyeballs" ("eyeballs" is the new "earnings"!). The admonishments of the exasperated spectators (Julian Robertson & Dr. Robert Shiller come to mind), like those of countless children on Saturday morning, were there if you cared to listen -"Look out! You're going to fall!"

The Shanghai Composite has been running off the cliff for quite some time now. (I'm not saying you can't make money there. It's hitting new highs everyday, but if a market up over 200% in 2 years isn't a bubble... what is?) And the warnings coming from land are getting louder. But the coyote never listens. And he doesn't appear to hear Mandarin any better than English. He is far too engrossed in his pursuit to pay any mind anyway. But he'll look down at some point.

In the same way that the tragic coyote defies the laws of physics, investors defy the laws of economics, running on air as the market soars... 5%... 10%... 15%... I can't wait til next week!

But then the warning cries from the cliff break through to the investor's consciousness. And one looks down. (Sell). Then another. (Sell). Then another (Sell) and -- whoosh!-- (SELL! SELL! SELL!) -- the Panic, with its sickening plunge, is on.

And you don't need a sign that says, "Bye bye!" to know it.

Wile E. Coyote Syndrome (TM) at its finest.

So how do you approach this situation? Your wisdom (and high school physics) tells you to run back to land. But it's such a rush dancing off the ledge, and that's where the money is.

For one thing, do not underestimate human greed. Do not overestimate its reciprocal fear either. (Physics also teaches us that every action has an equal and opposite reaction, after all). Be prepared for both. Have cash available to pick the pieces off the ground. Anticipate the sectors to which people will flee. Run around on air for awhile, but take some profits too. Most of all, prepare yourself emotionally for the plunge, because its coming. And no one know when.

The great thing about ol' Wile E. is that when he gets smushed, flattened, and blown up, he bounces back good as new in the next clip.

Investors aren't so lucky. Raise your hand if you bought Intel at 90! (You can't see my hand, it's up.) In fact, many portfolios never bounce back.

So enjoy it while you can. Be prepared for the plunge. And you may want to consider shorting "ACME Gadgets Co." (Their rocket boosters have serious design flaws.)

Labels: , , , , , , , ,

Saturday, May 05, 2007

What's Your Ben & Jerry's Investing Moment?

The market has been setting a new record everyday now it seems. The Dow Jones Industrial Average closed on Friday at 13,264.62, a new all time high. And the broader Standard & Poor 500 Index also closed at 1505.62, also a new all time high.

I had a conversation with a friend the other day who is an active investor, and I mentioned that I'm 20% cash. He was surprised.

"You don't need to be 20% in cash!", he explained. "You're not going to need that money for 30 years. You should be more aggressive!"

And he's totally right.

Sort of.

I could certainly stand to me more fully invested. After all, we're talking about a long term investing horizon. And as one who drank the Kool-Aid long ago on the long term safety of equities, I should be able to do so with confidence.

But here's the problem.

One's investing strategy does not exist in a vacuum. It is dependent upon one's Investing Personality. Modern Portfolio Theory does a great job of determining what asset allocation strategy will maximize your returns. But if that investing strategy is not consistent with one's risk preferences, emotional resilience - even attention span, it will succeed in theory, but fail in practice.

Think of it this way: Investing plans are a lot like eating plans. If you want to lose weight, there are any number of diets that will do the job. Barnes and Noble bookshelves are full of them. But what makes a diet right for you, is not whether it "would work" (heck, they pretty much all work). What makes the diet right for you is that it is the plan that you can stick to.

And like proper eating, we're not talking about a short-term, "look good for a wedding" type of situation with our investments. We're talking about following a lifetime plan of prudence and self-discipline. So any long term investment plan doesn't have a built in mechanism for those Ben & Jerry's moments is ultimately doomed to fail. That's why the right plan for me is a sub-optimal investing strategy.

They say that truth lies in paradox. Well here's one for you; I can't be aggressive without a more conservative asset allocation.

When I explained that (emotionally) I needed a decent chunk in cash, my friend assumed it was because I needed to know that at least a part of my portfolio was "risk free". Actually, that doesn't quite hit it.

It's not that the money is "risk free" (i.e., I can't lose it). In fact, the cash position for me gets mentally classified as a loss; I feel like I'm losing money by not having it participate in the rally. No. The reason I need that money in cash is entirely different.

I don't mind risk. In fact, I like being aggressive. But in order to be aggressive (e.g., take some more speculative positions), I need a sense of control. I need to know that if the market gets whacked, I have cash ready to take advantage of it. That way I can cognitively reframe a "bad day" (lost money) into a "good day" (got some bargains). If I couldn't do that, the bad days would overwhelm my portfolio and knock me off course.

For me, losing money only becomes emotionally intolerable when I'm unable to take action, when I can't reclaim some sense of control.

That's my wings/pizza/cheesecake moment. That's when I screw up my plan.

What's your weakness? What are the temptations that push you off your plan? We invite you to check out some of Marketpsych.com's investor self-assessment tools to determine where you (or your client's) potential vulnerabilities may lie.

In the meantime, eat healthy and enjoy the bull market.

Labels: , , ,

Tuesday, March 13, 2007

Investor Fear and Liquidity

“The key to making money in stocks is not to get scared out of them.”
~Peter Lynch

The market volatility the last few weeks has led to media speculation about possible causes: China's late February market plunge, the precarious financial straights of subprime mortgage lenders, and the biggest baddest reason of all .... Recession. In a different market climate, such events would have had little impact. But the market price action is now driven by emotional investors. By understanding how investors' fear generally plays out during such times, one can act proactively (rather than reacting) to such emotional markets.

Markets worldwide have been booming. In fact, on February 21st during a trip to India last month, I met the head of Asian investments for one of the largest New York-based hedge funds. He confided to me that "nothing in the world is cheap right now." And that was true for every broad asset class. In fact, the conclusion of our conversation was, "Only volatility is cheap." And that's a frightening position to be in. Within 2 days of our conversation the Bombay Sensex index began its latest correction, to be followed shortly by the Chinese and worldwide sell-off.

Many pundits have identified the "global liquidity glut" as the force behind stock market and commodity booms worldwide. But what is liquidity, really? Liquidity represents confidence -- the sense that one can borrow and make a greater return on their investments than the risk-free rate of return. And what is confidence but the lack of fear?

Today's sell-off is an opportunity. Many people who recently acquired risky assets are heading for the exits. But like last May, soon there will be a great time to load up on emerging market bargains.

Hundreds of billions of dollars have been committed to private equity, venture capital, and stock market investments in emerging markets. These outlays will be made over several years and will support emerging markets generally.

However, as with every opportunity, it's usually when it feels the hardest to buy, that the best price is available.

Richard

Labels: , , , ,